Why rebuild
A published number is a claim. Each project here takes one that mattered, a table a regulator read, a trial that changed a treatment, a finding people still cite, and rebuilds it from the public data instead of trusting the page. Then it asks the question the result was meant to answer: send the postcard or not, vaccinate here or there, stop the test now or wait.
What counts as a match
A match means the same number, to the last digit the source printed: the authors’ Stata log for NeighborsMailer, the 2006 SAS output for AncovaThreeWays, the 1955 report’s tables for PlaceboVsObserved. When a number does not match, it stays on the page with the reason. The four misses in PlaceboVsObserved are the report’s own. GapYears moved because WHO revised every country-year after the paper, and the rerun shows both.
Three languages
Where a project has Python and R, each was written on its own and the run compares them, so one language’s bug cannot hide in the other. Lean comes in where the decision can be stated exactly. It computes the verdict in whole numbers or exact fractions, with no rounding, and its kernel checks it. Lean does not fit a model that comes out of an optimiser, since certifying that would need a convergence proof, so those numbers stay with Python and R.
Run it yourself
Every environment is pinned with Nix. Where a repository is public, one command rebuilds everything from the raw downloads:
nix run github:gauranii/GapYears
The Proof Grid shows what each project was checked against, and the Full List has every run command.
Why a >
The mark at the top of Projects is a > drawn as a small graph. Here it means four things.
A prompt. R prints > when it is ready for you to type, a habit it kept from S, the Bell Labs language it was built to copy. Every project here ends in a command you can type yourself.
Greater than. Most of these projects end on one comparison: is the gap bigger than zero, and by how much.
An arrow. In a causal diagram, an arrow says this leads to that. The dots on the mark are steps, and each one feeds the next: the raw download, the cleaned table, the model, the number the paper printed.
A quote. In an email, > marks words someone else wrote. Every project starts from a number someone else published, copied exactly before it is checked.